Choosing a giveaway winner from Instagram comments: what makes it fair
A giveaway is simple to announce and awkward to finish. The post gets hundreds of comments, some
people comment ten times, some tag nobody, and in the end you have to choose one name and be able to
explain why it is that one. A good random winner picker takes the guesswork out of that last step.
Why Instagram has no comment picker of its own
Instagram shows comments, but it does not give you a way to turn them into a list of entries, apply
rules to it and draw from it. So people copy names by hand, paste them into a wheel or a spreadsheet,
and hope the result is believed. Pickmint does the collecting, the counting and the drawing in one
browser tab.
Rules first, then the draw
Fairness starts with the rules you announced. Pickmint lets you set them before the draw: one chance
per person so that commenting many times does not help, a required word or hashtag, a minimum number
of tagged friends, a minimum number of likes, a date range, whether replies count, and whether the
post owner or any named accounts are left out. It shows how many people are in the draw and how many
entries each rule left out, so you can say exactly what happened.
Winners, backups and a proof you can show
Pick one winner or several, and add backups for the day somebody does not answer. Every draw saves a
random number and a fingerprint of the list of entries, and gives the result a proof code. Press
Check again and Pickmint repeats the draw from that record: the same winners must come out.
If the list or the result was changed afterwards, the check fails. A proof file lets someone else run
the same check.
A stage that is ready to record
Most people show the draw on video. Recording mode hides the controls and leaves a clean screen for
your screen recorder, with a countdown, a winner reveal, balloons and confetti in the Aurora or the
Party style, in a quick, normal or big show. Sound is available and starts switched off, and the
animated effects are skipped if your system asks for reduced motion.
Downloading the comments without a draw
Sometimes the comments are the whole point. Once Pickmint has collected a post, one button saves
every comment as a spreadsheet file that opens in Excel, with the username, the text, the likes, the
replies, the date and a link to the profile. The same list can be saved as JSON. People use it to
review a campaign, sort entries, check who tagged whom or keep a record, and none of it needs a
giveaway.
Collecting comments at a steady pace
Asking Instagram for comments too fast can slow your session down, so Pickmint collects them
gradually and tells you how long it will take before you start. Not every comment is handed over;
some are hidden, filtered or deleted, and the number on a post includes replies. Pickmint shows both
numbers, the one the post reports and the one it collected. Keep the tab open until collection ends.
If it was closed, Pickmint continues where it stopped.
Privacy: what leaves your computer
Nothing is sent to us. There is no account and no sign-in, and Pickmint never asks for your
Instagram password. The comments, your rules and your past giveaways stay in your browser on your
device. Pickmint connects only to the post page to read its comments, to the image servers for
profile pictures, and to addonschrome.com to show the list of our extensions. Running giveaways on
TikTok too? See
TokDraw.
Cleaning up your own Instagram account? Have a look at
Followprune
and
Instagram Unfollow AI.
Pickmint is an independent extension. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, sponsored by, or in any
way officially connected to Meta Platforms, Inc., or any of its subsidiaries or affiliates.
“Instagram” and related names, marks and logos are trademarks of their respective owners
and appear here only to describe what this extension works with.